Disclaimer: Medicare.org is a non-government website owned and operated by Health Network Group, LLC., an Allstate company. HealthCompare, a licensed insurance agency, may compensate us when you enroll in a plan through our phone number or MedicareEnrollment.com. However, this does not influence our publication. Our opinions are our own.

Medicare.org

A Non-Government Guide to Learn About Medicare

Talk to a Licensed Insurance Agent[1]

833-453-3041 (TTY 711)

Mon-Fri 5am-6pm, Sat 6am-5pm PST

Chapter 5: Medicare Is Individual – Why You and Your Spouse Might Need Different Plans

When you and your spouse reach retirement age, it’s tempting to think that choosing the same Medicare plan is the simplest and best option. After all, you’ve likely been on the same health insurance plan for years. However, Medicare is different, and the best plan for you might not be the best plan for your spouse.

In this chapter, we’ll explore why Medicare is an individual decision and why it’s essential to evaluate your needs separately from your spouse’s.

A couple in their 60s sits together, each looking at separate Medicare plan brochures. The woman smiles confidently, while the man appears deep in thought, representing the individual nature of Medicare decisions.

Different Health Needs Require Different Plans

One of the most important reasons to evaluate Medicare options individually is that you and your spouse likely have different healthcare needs. Factors like chronic conditions, prescription medications, and frequency of doctor visits can all impact which plan is best for each of you.

  1. Chronic Conditions: If one of you has a chronic condition that requires frequent visits to specialists or specific treatments, a Medicare Advantage plan with a strong network of providers might be ideal. Meanwhile, the other spouse in good health might benefit more from Original Medicare with a lower-cost Medigap plan.
  2. Prescription Drugs: If one spouse takes several prescription medications, a Part D plan with comprehensive drug coverage might be necessary. The other spouse, who takes fewer medications, could choose a more basic plan with a lower premium.
  3. Routine vs. Specialized Care: A Medicare Advantage plan with lower copayments for routine services might be beneficial if one spouse needs regular checkups and preventive care. The other spouse might prefer the flexibility of Original Medicare for occasional visits to specialists.

Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage: A Personal Choice

Choosing between Medigap and Medicare Advantage is a highly personal decision. It should be made based on your individual healthcare needs rather than simply following what your spouse chooses.

  1. Medigap for Comprehensive Coverage: Medigap may be the better option if you prefer predictable costs and the freedom to choose any doctor who accepts Medicare. However, Medigap plans come with higher premiums, so it’s important to weigh the costs against the benefits.
  2. Medicare Advantage for Lower Premiums: Medicare Advantage plans often have lower premiums than Medigap, but they come with network restrictions. If you’re comfortable with the plan’s network and don’t mind paying copayments as you go, this could be a cost-effective choice.

Cost Differences Between Spouses

Medicare costs vary significantly between spouses, especially if you choose different plans. Understanding the potential differences in premiums, deductibles, and out-of-pocket expenses is essential.

  1. Medigap Costs: If one spouse chooses a Medigap plan, they may have higher premiums but lower out-of-pocket costs, as Medigap covers many expenses not paid by Original Medicare, such as the $1,632 deductible and the 20% coinsurance for doctor visits.
  2. Medicare Advantage Costs: The other spouse, on a Medicare Advantage plan, may have lower premiums but higher copayments and coinsurance for services. Additionally, Medicare Advantage plans have an out-of-pocket maximum, which is capped at $8,550 in 2024.

Enrollment and Timing Considerations

When making Medicare decisions, it’s also essential to consider each spouse’s enrollment periods and potential penalties. Enrollment timing may differ depending on whether one of you is still working or has other insurance coverage.

  1. Initial Enrollment Period (IEP): Each spouse has their Initial Enrollment Period when they turn 65. Both of you must enroll on time to avoid late enrollment penalties. For Part B, this penalty can add 10% to your premium for life.
  2. Special Enrollment Periods (SEP): If one spouse is still working and covered by employer insurance, they may qualify for a Special Enrollment Period. However, the other spouse may not, so it’s essential to coordinate your enrollment periods carefully.

Key Mistake: Automatically Choosing the Same Plan as Your Spouse

One of couples’ biggest mistakes is automatically choosing the same Medicare plan without considering their individual needs. While it might seem convenient, it can lead to higher costs or inadequate coverage for one or both of you. Evaluating your options separately can ensure that each of you gets the best possible coverage for your healthcare needs.

Conclusion

Medicare is not a one-size-fits-all solution, even for couples. By evaluating your healthcare needs individually and selecting the best plan, you can ensure you get the coverage you need while managing costs effectively.

In the next chapter, we’ll look at assistance programs that can help lower your Medicare costs, even if you think you don’t qualify.

Chapter 6: Assistance Programs You May Not Know About